Insurance Coverage That Fits Your Life
From your home and car to your business—we’ve got you covered with customized protection for everything that matters.
Affordable Coverage
Quality insurance protection at competitive, fair rates.
Experienced Team
Licensed agents with deep knowledge across personal and business insurance lines.
Reliable Carriers
We partner with top-rated insurance companies to offer dependable, flexible coverage.
Client-First Approach
Personalized service and support, from your first quote to filing a claim.
About us
Protecting What Matters Most
At Fairway Insurance Agency, we’re a family-owned insurance agency proudly serving New York as well as many surrounding states. Our licensed team offers personalized insurance solutions tailored to your home, business, and vehicle needs. Partnering with top carriers, we provide comprehensive coverage and exceptional service to give you peace of mind. As active members of the Long Island community, we’re committed to protecting what matters most to you.
- Personal Insurance Solutions
- Business Insurance Coverage
- Specialized Policies for Vehicles
What We Offer
Comprehensive Insurance Solutions
Home & Property Insurance
Protect your home, condo, or rental property with the right policy.
Auto & Vehicle Coverage
From everyday drivers to collector cars, we’ve got you covered.
Flood Insurance
Safeguard your assets from major losses and unexpected events.
Business Insurance
Tailored protection for small businesses, contractors, and commercial operations.
Why US
Our Commitment to Coverage You Can Count On
Industry Expertise
Our team brings years of hands-on experience and deep product knowledge to every policy.
Tailored Plans
We don’t do cookie-cutter coverage, your plan is built around your exact needs.
Trusted Partners
We work with top insurance carriers to ensure you get reliable, cost-effective protection.
Testimonials
What Our Clients Are Saying
Sarah M.
St. James, NY
Working with Anthony and his team was so easy. They walked me through every step and made sure I had the right coverage for my antique shop!
Mark D.
Commack, NY
Fairway helped me insure my vehicles, shop, and warehouse all under one plan. Super professional and responsive.
Our Team
Anthony Galano
Producer
(631) 745-7855
agalano@fairwayinsny.com
Jake Romano
Owner
(631) 394-1406
jromano@fairwayinsny.com
John Horl
Producer / CSR
(631) 953-1252
jhorl@fairwayinsny.com
At Fairway Insurance we are proud to lead a team that’s committed to helping individuals, families, and businesses protect what matters most.
We understand that quality insurance isn’t one-size-fits-all—it takes a personal approach, the right planning, and the guidance of experienced professionals. That’s exactly what you’ll find at Fairway.
With access to a wide range of top-rated carriers and coverage options, we’re here to help you build a reliable insurance plan tailored to your unique needs—whether it’s your home, car, business, or recreational assets like boats and jet skis.
Thank you for visiting our site! Take a look around and don’t hesitate to reach out if you have questions or want to request a quote. We’re here to help you move forward with confidence.